| When is a dirty bathroom a broken window?No, | | | | We don't even necessarily |
| that's not a riddle. It's a question that | | | | |
| could today be at the | | | | patronize those companies that fix their |
| | | | broken windows, if the less |
| core of a business's success or | | | | |
| failure.Answer that question correctly | | | | attentive one is in a more convenient |
| | | | location or has a slightly lower |
| and use that answer as a beacon, and your | | | | |
| business could dominate its | | | | price.That's not to say we are all to blame |
| | | | when a company has |
| competition indefinitely.Ignore the solution | | | | |
| to the puzzle, and you | | | | broken windows and doesn't fix them, but it |
| | | | does mean we all bear |
| will be condemning your business to failure | | | | |
| in a very short period of | | | | some responsibility to stand up for what we |
| | | | actually want and have |
| time.The "broken windows" theory, first put | | | | |
| forth by criminologist | | | | every right to expect out of a company to |
| | | | which we're giving our hard-earned |
| James Q. Wilson and George L. Kelling in a | | | | |
| piece called "Broken | | | | money.In a capitalist society, we can assume |
| | | | that a company |
| Windows" in the Atlantic Monthly magazine in | | | | |
| March 1982, explains | | | | that wants to succeed will do its best to |
| | | | fulfill the desired of its |
| what a broken window is in criminal justice | | | | |
| terms.But the brilliance | | | | consuming public.If the company sees sales |
| | | | slipping but doesn't have |
| of that theory goes much further than one | | | | |
| interpretation. It can and | | | | data from consumers as to what made them |
| | | | decrease their spending on |
| should be applied to business, too, and it | | | | |
| can make a critical | | | | a retail level, the company will not |
| | | | necessarily know what to fix.Still, |
| difference- if American businesses will | | | | corporations and even small businesses that |
| simply take the time and have | | | | don't notice |
| | | | |
| the courage to notice.When Wilson and | | | | and repair their broken windows should not |
| Kelling first unveiled the theory, the idea | | | | simply be forgiven |
| of | | | | |
| | | | because their consumers didn't make enough |
| concentrating on seemingly petty criminal | | | | of a fuss.It is the |
| acts like graffiti or purse | | | | |
| | | | responsibility of the business to tend to |
| snatching seemed absurd: How would a | | | | its own house.The owner of a |
| crackdown on jaywalking lead | | | | |
| | | | Starbucks franchise who decides that |
| to a decrease in murders?The broken windows | | | | revenues are at a healthy level, |
| theory states that something as small and | | | | |
| | | | such that he or she can put off painting the |
| innocuous as a broken window does in fact | | | | store for another year, is |
| send a signal to those who | | | | |
| | | | asking for trouble:Yes, things are fine now, |
| pass by every day. If it is left broken, the | | | | but when the paint is |
| owner of the building isn't | | | | |
| | | | faded and peeling and consumers are no |
| paying attention or doesn't care.That means | | | | longer getting the experience |
| more serious | | | | |
| | | | they've come to expect, it will be too late |
| infractions...theft, | | | | to fix things with, literally, a |
| | | | |
| defacement, violent crime- might be condoned | | | | fresh coat of paint.The time to repair |
| in this area as | | | | broken windows is the minute |
| | | | |
| well.At best, it signals that no one is | | | | they occur.It's better, however, to prevent |
| watching.This is the heart of the broken | | | | such smashed panes of glass to |
| windows theory: Wilson and | | | | |
| | | | begin with.This book will examine the |
| Kelling write that "social psychologists and | | | | origins of broken windows into |
| police officers tend to | | | | |
| | | | two purposes in mind. First, we will see how |
| agree that if a window in a building is | | | | the small things that can snowball into |
| broken and is left unrepaired, all | | | | |
| | | | large problems develop so we can best |
| the rest of the windows will soon be | | | | illustrate how to |
| broken."Why?Because | | | | |
| | | | repair the damage once it's been done.But it |
| the | | | | is equally important to |
| | | | |
| message being sent out by a broken window- | | | | see how these things happen so that a smart |
| the perception it invites is | | | | business owner can make |
| | | | |
| that the owner of this building and the | | | | sure to prevent them at- or before- the very |
| people of the community | | | | first sign of trouble.If you |
| | | | |
| around it don't care if this window is | | | | have a policy to paint the store every year, |
| broken:They have given up, and | | | | you'll never have to worry |
| | | | |
| anarchy reigns here.Do as you will, because | | | | about whether this was the year you waited |
| nobody cares.Wilson and Kelling suggested | | | | too long.In order to best understand how the |
| that a "broken window"- any | | | | broken windows theory |
| | | | |
| small indication that something is amiss and | | | | relates to business, it's important to |
| not being repaired- can | | | | examine the original theory- as it |
| | | | |
| lead to much larger problems.It sends | | | | related to criminal activity- in some |
| signals, they said, that the bad | | | | detail. Because of the brilliant |
| | | | |
| guys are in charge here; no one cares about | | | | thinking of Wilson and Kelling, "Broken |
| maintaining some kind of | | | | Windows" illustrated a |
| | | | |
| order, and anyone who wishes to take | | | | serious societal problem that was going |
| advantage of that situation | | | | unnoticed, and helped turn |
| | | | |
| would be unopposed.It leads to lawlessness, | | | | around some of the country's largest cities |
| a kind of anarchy by | | | | (including the largest of all) |
| | | | |
| neglect."Just as physicians now recognize | | | | by paying attention to detail.It began with |
| the importance of fostering | | | | a program in New Jersey in the mid 1970s. The |
| | | | |
| health rather than simply treating illness, | | | | Safe and Clean Neighborhoods Program was |
| so the police- and the rest of | | | | meant to improve the |
| | | | |
| us- ought to recognize the importance of | | | | quality of life in twenty-eight Garden State |
| maintaining, intact, | | | | cities, and it was to do so, |
| | | | |
| communities without broken windows," wrote | | | | in part, by increasing the number of police |
| Wilson and Kelling.Years later, Wilson told | | | | officers on foot patrol, |
| me that the idea behind the broken | | | | |
| | | | rather than in patrol cars. Police chiefs, |
| windows theory "had to do with the | | | | Wilson says today, felt that |
| responsibility of the police to take | | | | |
| | | | such a move was not likely to lower crime |
| seriously small signs of disorder because | | | | levels, "and the police |
| people were afraid of | | | | |
| | | | chiefs were right: They didn't have an |
| disorder, and there was a chance disorder | | | | effect on crime rates. But they |
| could lead to more serious | | | | |
| | | | did have an effect- and in my view, a |
| crime."Still, critics of the theory greeted | | | | powerful effect- on how people |
| it with skepticism, believing | | | | |
| | | | felt about their communities and their |
| that attention to small infractions would | | | | willingness to use it, suggesting |
| necessarily would necessarily | | | | |
| | | | that fear of disorder was as important as |
| decrease the amount of attention that could | | | | fear of crime."Indeed, as Wilson and Kelling |
| be devoted to much more | | | | wrote in the Atlantic, "residents |
| | | | |
| serious crimes.The same objection, in | | | | of the foot-patrolled neighborhoods seemed |
| slightly less genteel verbiage, was | | | | to feel more secure than |
| | | | |
| raised when Rudolph Giuliani, the newly | | | | persons in other areas, tended to believe |
| elected mayor of New York | | | | that crime had been reduced, |
| | | | |
| City in 1994, announced his intention to | | | | and seemed to take fewer steps to protect |
| eliminate graffiti on subway | | | | themselves from crime |
| | | | |
| cars and move the hookers and pimps out of | | | | (staying at home with the doors locked, for |
| Times Square, to make | | | | example).Moreover, |
| | | | |
| Manhattan more "family-friendly."Critics | | | | citizens in the foot-patrol areas had a more |
| practically laughed in | | | | favorable opinion than did |
| | | | |
| Giuliani's face, intimating that the "law | | | | those living elsewhere."What does this all |
| and order" mayor- who had | | | | mean to business?It's not likely that having |
| | | | |
| been elected based largely on his experience | | | | police officers walk the aisles of a |
| as a U.S. attorney for the | | | | Wal-Mart store will increase sales. |
| | | | |
| New York area- was dealing with the small | | | | But it was the perception that something was |
| crimes because he knew he | | | | being done to increase |
| | | | |
| couldn't contain the larger ones.They were | | | | order that made the difference for the |
| proved wrong.Giuliani and his new police | | | | people living in these New |
| | | | |
| commissioner, William Bratton, believed that | | | | Jersey cities.In a business (as we'll |
| if they sent out clear | | | | discuss in detail through out this book), the |
| | | | broken windows |
| signals to criminals, and to New York's | | | | |
| citizenry generally, that a | | | | can be literal or metaphorical.Sometimes a |
| | | | |
| "zero tolerance" policy would be applied to | | | | broken window really is a broken window, and |
| all crime in the city, the | | | | a new pane of glass |
| | | | |
| result would be a safer, cleaner city.And | | | | needs to be installed as quickly as |
| the statistics bore them out: | | | | possible. Most of the time, however, |
| | | | |
| Over the following years, the numbers of | | | | broken windows are the little details, the |
| murders, assaults, robberies, | | | | tiny flaws, the overlooked |
| | | | |
| and other violent crimes all went down | | | | minutiae, that signal much larger problems |
| dramatically.And it had all | | | | either already in place or |
| | | | |
| started with graffiti on subway cars.I can | | | | about to become reality.We'll examine |
| hear you asking, "What does that have to do | | | | companies- huge ones, household names- that |
| with my | | | | |
| | | | have failed to notice and repair their |
| business? It's all about crime and | | | | broken windows and have |
| criminals."That same theory is applicable to | | | | |
| the world of business. | | | | suffered greatly for it.We'll also look at |
| | | | those that have made it a |
| If the restroom at the local Burger King is | | | | |
| out of toilet paper, it | | | | priority to attend to every potentially |
| | | | broken window and ordered |
| signals that management isn't paying | | | | |
| attention to the needs of its | | | | plenty of replacement panes to make quick, |
| | | | seamless repairs.The |
| clientele. That could lead the consumer to | | | | |
| conclude that food at this | | | | lessons learned will be many, and varied, |
| | | | and they will have happy, |
| restaurant might not be prepared adequately, | | | | |
| that there might be health | | | | and not-so-happy endings.Sometimes companies |
| | | | that deserve to be |
| risks in coming here, or that the entire | | | | |
| chain of fast food out outlets | | | | rebuked for their laziness will go |
| | | | unpunished, but other times there |
| simply doesn't care about its | | | | |
| customers.Given that scenario, it is not a | | | | will be retribution at the hands of the |
| stretch of the imagination but in | | | | public, which shows exactly |
| | | | |
| fact a point of logic to conclude that the | | | | what happens when you give people what they |
| broken windows theory | | | | don't want.What the public wants more than |
| | | | anything else is to feel that |
| should be applied to business, as it was to | | | | |
| the problems of crime in | | | | the business- retail or service-oriented, |
| | | | consumer or business-to-business- |
| urban areas.Certainly, the perception of the | | | | |
| average consumer is a | | | | that work for them care about what they |
| | | | want.Consumers |
| vital part of every business, and if a | | | | |
| retailer, service provider, or | | | | are looking for businesses that anticipate |
| | | | and fulfill their needs and do |
| corporation is sending out signals that its | | | | |
| approach is lackadaisical, its | | | | so in a way that makes it clear the business |
| | | | understand the consumer's |
| methods halfhearted, and its execution | | | | |
| indifferent, the business in | | | | needs or wants and is doing its best to see |
| | | | them satisfied.Broken windows indicate to the |
| question could suffer severe- and in some | | | | consumer that the business |
| cases, irreparable- losses.This book is about | | | | |
| broken windows in business: how they | | | | doesn't care- either that it is so poorly |
| | | | run it can't possibly keep up |
| happen, why they happen, why they are | | | | |
| ignored, and the fatal | | | | with its obligations or that it has become |
| | | | so oversize and arrogant that |
| consequences that can result from their | | | | |
| being allowed to go | | | | it no longer cares about its core consumer. |
| | | | Either of these impressions |
| unchecked.It is meant as a cautionary tale, | | | | |
| a primer, a road map, a | | | | can be deadly to a business, and we'll see |
| | | | examples of both as we |
| manifesto, and a salute to those companies | | | | |
| that fix their broken | | | | proceed.If you run a business, and you truly |
| | | | believe that little things |
| windows promptly.It will explore not only | | | | |
| specific examples of | | | | don't make a difference, you really should |
| | | | read this book- it may save |
| broken windows, how they occurred, and what | | | | |
| their long-term results | | | | your business.If you don't run a business |
| | | | but would like to, this can be |
| were but also the culture that creates an | | | | |
| environment in which | | | | the road map to your success. IF you're |
| | | | merely interested in business |
| windows are broken and left unfixed.I | | | | |
| believe that small things make a huge | | | | and wonder why one succeeds where a very |
| difference in business.The messy condiment | | | | similar one fails, perhaps |
| area at a fast food restaurant may lead | | | | |
| | | | the examples contained here might help |
| consumers to believe the company as a whole | | | | answer that question for you.But it can't be |
| doesn't care about | | | | overemphasized that tiny details- the |
| | | | smaller, |
| cleanliness, and therefore the food itself | | | | |
| might be in question.Indifferent help at the | | | | the more important- can indeed make a |
| counter in an upscale clothing store-even if | | | | tremendous difference in a |
| just | | | | |
| | | | business's success or failure.Sometimes, |
| one clerk- can signal to the consumer that | | | | yes, a company can make a |
| perhaps standards here | | | | |
| | | | huge mistake (the whole New Coke thing was |
| aren't as high as they might be (or used to | | | | less a broken window |
| be).An employee at the gas | | | | |
| | | | than a neutron bomb placed dead center on |
| station who wears a T-shirt with an | | | | corporate headquarters), |
| offensive slogan can certainly | | | | |
| | | | but often, even those are foreshadowed by |
| cause some customers to switch brands of | | | | the little things that go, alas, |
| gasoline and lose an | | | | |
| | | | unnoticed.A broken window can be a sloppy |
| enormous company those customers for | | | | counter, a poorly located |
| life.But that's only the tip of the iceberg. | | | | |
| I think we as a society | | | | sale item, a randomly organized menu, or an |
| | | | employee with a bad |
| have fostered and encouraged broken windows | | | | |
| in our business by | | | | attitude.It can be physical, like a faded, |
| | | | flaking paint job, or symbolic, |
| standing by and letting them happen. If the | | | | |
| waiter at a local chain | | | | like a policy that requires consumers to pay |
| | | | for customer service.When the waiter at a |
| restaurant is impolite, or even merely | | | | Chinese restaurant is named Billy Bob, that's |
| complacent, about our order, we | | | | a |
| | | | |
| chalk it up to a bad day, one employee in | | | | broken window.When a call for help |
| one outlet of a large chain, | | | | assembling a bicycle results in a |
| | | | |
| and we don't send a letter to management or | | | | twenty-minute hold on the phone (playing the |
| the corporate level.Even | | | | same music over and |
| | | | |
| if we do change brands of gasoline after | | | | over), that's a broken window. When a |
| seeing an attendant in an | | | | consumer asks why she can't |
| | | | |
| offensive T-shirt, we do not write or e-mail | | | | return her blouse at the counter and it |
| the president of the oil | | | | told, "Because that's the rule," |
| | | | |
| company to alert him to the problem.We are | | | | that is a broken window.They're |
| enablers to window | | | | everywhere.Except at the really sharp |
| | | | businesses.Read on. |
| breakers in every aspect of every business. | | | | |